A Question of Trust

39 questionsCBSE 2027
20 min read
Share:

Study Notes

A QUESTION OF TRUST
SUMMARY

Victor Canning wrote "A Question of Trust". It's about Horace Danby, a thief who seemed like a good guy. He was fifty and worked as a locksmith. He was also a successful businessman with two helpers. Despite his respectable appearance, he wasn't entirely honest. He had a passion for rare books and would steal to buy them secretly. Every year, he'd plan a burglary to fund his hobby. This time, he targeted a house at Shotover Grange, studying it carefully for two weeks.

The family who lived in the house was away in London. One afternoon, the two caretakers left to watch a movie. Horace saw this as his chance to break in. He came out from behind a garden wall, carrying his tools in a bag. He took a key from the hook on the kitchen door. Putting on gloves to avoid leaving fingerprints, he opened the door. Inside, he saw the dog, Sherry, wagging its tail at him.

Danby knew the safe was hidden behind a painting in the drawing room. There was a vase of flowers on the table, but Danby was allergic to the scent. He sneezed a lot as he worked to disable the burglar alarm. Suddenly, he heard a young lady's voice behind him. She was dressed in red and pretended to be the homeowner's wife. She told Danby she needed her jewels for a party that night. Danby believed her and allowed her to collect them.

Danby, feeling relieved that he had escaped the lady's trap, left the house and returned home, believing he had successfully avoided imprisonment. However, his relief was short-lived, as on the third day, the police arrived and arrested him for the burglary of the jewels at Shotover Grange. Despite his initial confidence in his escape, Danby's clever burglary had not gone unnoticed, and the authorities had managed to trace the stolen jewels back to him. This turn of events led to Danby's eventual arrest and legal consequences for his actions.

Horace Danby's fingerprints were found all over the house he robbed. Eventually, he confessed to the crime, admitting that he had opened the safe for a woman but hadn't taken any jewels. However, his story didn't hold up as the real owner's wife was not the young woman he described. The police quickly arrested him, and he was sent to prison. While serving his sentence, he worked as an assistant librarian. Danby often thought about the clever woman who had deceived him. Whenever someone mentioned "honour among thieves," he would become angry and upset.
Short Answer Type Questions
Short Answer Types Question (SAQ)

1. How did Horace know all the details of the house?

Answer : Horace had spent the past two weeks studying the house. Additionally, a magazine article described the house, providing a floor plan of all the rooms and a picture of one of the rooms. The article also included details about the location of the hidden safe.
2. How did Horace fulfill his desire of reading books after he was arrested?

Answer : After Horace was arrested, he became the assistant librarian in the prison and fulfilled his desire for reading books.
3. Though Horace planned everything meticulously, why did he fail?

Answer : Despite Horace's careful planning, he failed because of the clever lady. She pretended to be the owner of the house and convinced him to open the safe because she claimed she didn't know the password. Horace fell into her trap.
4. How did the flowers cause him trouble?

Answer : Horace Danby had an allergy to flowers, especially during pollen season. When flowers were nearby, he started sneezing. The only way to stop it was to stay away from those flowers.
5. What was Horace Danby’s hobby? How did he manage to fulfill his hobby?

Answer : Horace’s only hobby was to read expensive and rare books. He used to rob a safe every year in order to arrange money for his hobby. He used to get those books from an agent.
6. How did the lady spoil his plan?

Answer : The lady pretended to be the owner of the house in front of Horace. Horace got scared and believed her. She asked him to open the safe as she had forgotten the password. Horace opened the safe and handed over the jewels to her. Hence, Horace’s plan of robbing the safe was spoiled.
7. Why did the lady report to the police though she promised that she would not report to the police?
Or
How did the lady deceive Horace?


Answer : The lady was very clever and cunning. She promised Horace that she would not tell the police if he helped her get the jewels from the safe. Horace broke the safe and helped her. But she didn’t keep her promise because she was also a thief and didn’t want to get caught.
8. How did Horace enter Shot over Grange?

Answer : Horace had watched the housekeeper hang the key on the hook outside the kitchen door. Then, he emerged from behind the garden wall. After putting on his gloves, he took the key and opened the kitchen door to enter Shotover Grange.
9. Who is the real culprit in this story, the lady or Horace? How did he/she manage to rob the safe without leaving a single fingerprint?

Answer : In this story, the young woman is actually the one who did the stealing. She tricked Horace into opening the safe for her. She didn't even have to touch the safe herself. She got away with all the jewels without doing any physical work. That's how she managed to rob the safe without leaving any fingerprints behind.
10. What do you think is the meaning of the phrase ‘honor among thieves’?

Answer : The phrase ‘honor among thieves’ means that thieves have their code of conduct. One thief is honest to the other thief. They never betray one another.
11. Which of the two lacked honor?

Answer : The young lady didn't have honor. Even though she met a thief, she still tricked him. But Horace didn't know she was a thief. She took all the jewels and got away, but Horace got arrested. What she did wasn't right for thieves.
12. Describe Horace Danby.

Answer : Horace Danby was a good and respected man in town. He was around fifty years old and never got married. He worked as a locksmith and was quite successful. He usually stayed healthy, except for when he had hay fever. However, he wasn't entirely honest.
13. How did Horace Danby manage to get rare and expensive books?

Answer : Horace Danby really liked rare and costly books. He bought them secretly using someone else to do it for him. But to afford them, he had to steal from a safe every year because he didn't have enough money. That's how he got those special books.
14. What did the young lady asked Horace to do for her?

Answer : The young lady told Horace she was there to take the jewels from the safe for a party that night. She said she forgot the combination to open the safe and forced Horace to break it open for her. If he didn't, she threatened to tell the police everything about him.
15. What story did Horace tell the police when he was arrested?

Answer : He told the police he didn't steal any jewels. He said he opened the safe for the young wife of the homeowner. But the wife was actually an old lady around sixty years old with grey hair. So, no one believed his story.
16. Why is Horace Danby described as good and respectable but not completely honest?

Answer : Horace Danby was a good guy. He made locks and did well in his business. He had two helpers. But he wasn't entirely honest because he robbed a safe every year.
17. Why did he rob every year? Was he a typical thief? If so, why?

Answer : Horace loved reading rare and expensive books. So he robbed a safe every year to buy these books. He was a typical thief because he robbed only one safe every year.
18. Describe how Horace Danby planned his work?

Answer : Horace Danby spent two weeks studying the Shotover Grange house. He looked at its rooms, electric wiring, paths, and garden. He was sure the family was in London. The two servants had gone to the movies and wouldn't return for four hours. He came out from behind the garden wall and went into the house.
19. He was a very successful thief. What went wrong when he attempted to rob Shotover Grange?

Answer : Danby was a successful thief. He always wore gloves when breaking into safes so he wouldn't leave fingerprints. But this time, he felt a tickle in his nose because of a big flower pot on the table. He kept sneezing, which messed things up for him.
20. What advice did the lady give Horace regarding his hay fever? Was she really interested in his health?

Answer : The lady told Horace he could cure his illness if he figured out which plant caused it. She suggested he should see a doctor. She wasn't really concerned about his health; she was just trying to be nice and understanding.
21. Did the young lady expect Horace to be caught after the theft?

Answer : Yes, the young lady expected Horace to be caught after the theft. She thought that it would be very easy to detect Horace with the help of fingerprints.
22. In what way could his arrest have helped her?

Answer : If Horace Danby was caught for the jewel robbery at Shotover Grange, then she could be safe. She got the jewels, but Horace opened the safe for her. So, his arrest might have relieved her of worry.
23. Did Horace get the jewels from the Grange safe? If not, why did the police arrest him?

Answer : No, Horace did not get the jewels from the Grange safe. But he broke open the safe for the wife of the owner of the house without gloves. But in reality, that lady was a burglar. Thus, there were Horace’s fingerprints all over the room. So, the police arrested him for stealing the jewels from the Grange safe.
24. Who was Horace Danby?

Answer : Horace Danby was around fifty years old and not married. People believed he was a good and truthful person. He lived with a housekeeper who cared about his health. He had hay fever attacks in the summer. He worked as a locksmith and did well. However, he wasn't entirely honest. He stole from a safe once a year to buy expensive books.
25. Why was Horace Dan by not completely honest?

Answer : People usually believed that Horace Danby was a good, honest, and respectable person. But he wasn't completely honest. Every year, he stole from a safe to get money for buying rare and expensive books he loved. The money he stole lasted him a whole year. He bought the books secretly through someone else.
26. What preparations did Horace make for ‘this year’s robbery’ at Shotover Grange?

Answer : Horace Danby had successfully robbed safes every year before. He was confident that this year's robbery at Shotover Grange would also go smoothly. He spent two weeks studying the house, looking at its rooms, electric wiring, paths, and garden. He discovered that the two servants had gone to the movies. He also noticed the housekeeper hanging the key to the kitchen door on a hook outside.
27. How did Horace Danby enter the house?

Answer : Horace Danby prepared for the theft by studying the house for two weeks at Shotover Grange. He looked at its rooms, electric wiring, paths, and garden. He noticed the housekeeper hanging the kitchen door key outside. Wearing gloves, he took the key and unlocked the door, entering the house.
29. Why was it not hard to open the safe for Horace Danby?

Answer : Opening the safe wasn't difficult for Horace Danby because he was used to locks and safes. He made locks himself with two helpers. The burglar alarm wasn't well-made, so he cut its wires. He knew about the safe and the key, so it wasn't hard for him to open it when no one was around in the house.
30. Whose voice was it that advised Horace about the special treatment of his hay fever?

Answer : As Horace was about to open the safe, he heard a woman's voice. She asked if he had a cold or hay fever because he was sneezing a lot. She said he could cure hay fever with special treatment, and he needed to figure out which plant caused it. She also suggested he see a doctor.
31. Describe the unexpected meeting of the young lady in red and Horace.

Answer : When a voice suggested Horace find a treatment for his hay fever, he was surprised. It was a gentle voice but sounded firm. A young woman, looking pretty and wearing red clothes, stood there. She went to the fireplace and fixed the ornaments. She mentioned she didn't anticipate encountering a burglar.
32. Why did the woman in red threaten to call the police?

Answer : Horace got caught while in the act. The woman in red said she didn't think there would be a burglar there. She understood it must have been troublesome for him to encounter her. She asked what he planned to do. Horace said he was considering running away. The lady warned that if he did, she'd call the police and tell them everything about him, and they'd catch him immediately.
33. When and why did the woman in red say, “Society must be protected from men like you”? Doesn’t it sound ironical?

Answer : Horace promised the woman in red he wouldn't harm her and asked her to forget they met. This angered her because she couldn't let him go; otherwise, he might steal from someone else. Society needed to be protected from people like him. It's ironic because she herself was a thief and had come for the same reason Horace was in the house.
34. “I have always liked the wrong kind of people,” said the woman in red. Comment.

Answer : It was strange that the woman acting like she owned the house and talking confidently was actually a thief herself. Horace begged her to release him. He was scared of going to jail. He vowed never to steal again. The lady pretended to be kind and said she always had a soft spot for the wrong sort of people.
35. Why did Horace mistake the young lady in red as the lady of the house?

Answer : The young woman in red was cleverer than Horace Danby. She was also a thief and came to the house for the same reason as Horace. But she met Horace confidently and firmly. She didn't let him question or doubt her. She claimed the dog, Sherry, was hers. She said she came back "home" just in time. The way she talked, moved, and acted confidently made Horace think she was the owner of the house.
36. Do you think that the young woman in red proved far smarter than Horace Danby? Give reasons.

Answer : The young woman in red was definitely smarter than Horace Danby. She acted as if she owned the house perfectly. She showed great confidence and didn't hesitate at all. She spoke and acted like she was totally in charge. Horace was like a puppet under her control and couldn't break free from her influence. She threatened to call the police and made him open the safe. Later, Horace was caught and arrested, while she got away with the jewels.
37. Who is the real culprit in the story, the young lady in red or Horace Danby? Comment.

Answer : Law of any land works on evidence. Horace Danby opened the safe without wearing his gloves. He didn’t think it necessary to wear them as he thought he was working for ‘the lady of the house’. So the police matched his fingerprints and he was arrested. The lady in the red was actually the real culprit. She made Horace open the safe for her. She was also a thief and decamped with the jewels. But in the eyes of the law, Horace was the real culprit because the evidence was against him.
38. Why didn’t the dog bark when Horace Danby and the young lady in red entered to commit theft in the house?

Answer : Both Horace Danby and the young lady in red were skilled in their craft. They understood how to handle dogs and be friendly with them. When a small dog made noise, Horace called out "All right, Sherry," as he walked by. Perhaps, the lady in red also knew, like Horace, that to keep dogs quiet, you need to call them by their correct names. Their trick worked, and Sherry stayed quiet.
39. Why did Horace Danby prefer books to collect paintings?

Answer : Horace Danby loved books, especially rare and costly ones. It was his hobby to collect and buy them. To afford them, he robbed a safe every year. When he had to choose between collecting books and paintings, he picked books because they took up less space in his small house.
40. Why didn’t Horace Danby never get any chance to look for another safe?

Answer : Horace didn't get anything from the house at Shotover Grange. The lady in red took off with the jewels. He kept his promise to the lady for two days. On the third day, he realized he needed to find another safe to steal from to buy books. But he didn't get the chance because the police arrested him for the jewel robbery at Shotover Grange.
Long Answer Type Questions
1. “Horace had some hope because she seemed to be amused at meeting him.” Why did Horace feel so? Did he consider the young lady compassionate towards him? Did he find her free from bias? Discuss the values Horace should have imbibe understanding of the person in 100-120 words.

Answer : Horace, a fifty-year-old man, used to steal only to buy rare and expensive books. This time, he planned to rob Shotover Grange. But as soon as they entered the room, a young lady showed up, pretending to be the owner of the house. She was very confident and articulate in her speech. She talked about important ideals like being proactive and protecting society from thieves like him. Then she tried to be polite and friendly to him. On hearing her, Horace felt that he had a hope of escaping. He found her a bit compassionate towards him. He was amused at Horace. She acted in quite a subtle manner and showed her sympathy and admiration towards a simple and honest man. He couldn't see through her disguise. She made Horace promise he wouldn't steal again. Horace was clever and cunning, so he later got arrested for stealing jewels he didn't take.
2. Horace Danby requested the lady to forget what she saw. Was Horace afraid of being caught? Did he lack the courage to accept his crime publicly? Explain the values one must imbibe to accept one’s mistake in 100-120 words.

Answer : Yes, Horace Danby was afraid of being caught. He lacked the courage to accept his crime publicly. He was not a professional criminal or a thief. He was considered a good and honest man by everyone. He was about fifty years old and unmarried. His house was looked after by a housekeeper. He used to rob only one safe every year to pursue his habit of getting rare and expensive books to read. He used to rob only those who were rich. He had a good reputation in the society and hence did not want anyone to know about his crimes. Although he helped the lady but was caught by the police for a crime he did not commit. He learned from his mistake.
3. Give a character-sketch of the lady in red highlighting how she outwitted Horace Danby.

Answer : We don’t get any information regarding the past history of the lady in red as we know about Horace’s past. Her whole personality remains wrapped in mystery until the end. Only when the identity of the real lady of the house is unfolded, we come to know that she is a thief. She is the real culprit. The lady in red comes there with the only purpose of committing a theft in the house like Horace. She cleverly decamps with the jewels while Horace is sent to prison. The lady in red is gifted with a rare personality. She is full of confidence. She acts like a perfect actress presenting herself as the lady of the house. Her gestures, confidence and convincing power are enough to convince Horace. He turns out quite a novice in understanding and judging the lady in red and her motive. She dominates the proceeding. Horace only proves a puppet in her hands. She exploits his fear of going to prison. She makes him open the safe without his gloves. She convinced him that she needs those jewels to wear them to a party that night. Horace willingly hands over the jewels and she decamps with them. Only when the grey-haired, sharp-tongued woman appears as the real lady of the house, we come to know that the lady in red was a professional and crafty thief much smarter than Horace.
4. How was Horace Danby arrested for the robbery of the jewels in a house at Shotover Grange? Do you think his own foolishness was responsible for his arrest? Give a reasoned answer.

Answer : Horace Danby never rushed or acted carelessly when stealing. He robbed a safe every year, and all his past thefts had been successful. Even when planning to steal from a house at Shotover Grange, he made detailed and well-planned preparations. However, he was inexperienced compared to the young lady in red. She confidently and convincingly made him think she was the owner of the house. She made him open the safe without the gloves and handover all the jewels to her. She decamped with the jewels and Horace was arrested.

At noon, a policeman arrested Horace for stealing jewels from Shotover Grange. He had opened the safe without wearing gloves, believing he was doing it for the lady of the house. He pleaded that the wife of the owner of the house had asked him to open the safe for her. The actual lady of the house arrived. She wasn't the young lady in red, but an older woman with grey hair who was around sixty years old. She said Horace's story was untrue. That's when Horace realized he had been tricked by the lady in red, who was also a thief like him.
5. Write a character-sketch of Horace Danby.

Answer : Horace Danby was a good man, around fifty years old, but he never married. He worked as a locksmith and was quite successful. However, he wasn't entirely honest and had been to jail before. He really disliked the idea of going back to jail.

He adored rare and pricey books. Each year, he broke into a safe to get money for buying books. He was a cautious thief, planning his actions carefully. He was meticulous when robbing a safe, always wearing gloves to avoid leaving fingerprints. Being a locksmith, it was effortless for him to break into any safe.

Once he was duped by a young lady. That young lady, who pretended to be the owner’s wife, was also a thief. He gave all the jewels to the young lady and left his fingerprints all over the room. Thus, he was arrested and sent to prison. Now he did not like the thought of ‘honor among thieves’ anymore.
6. Describe Horace Danby’s encounter with the young lady.
Or
‘The lady in the red was a more professional thief than Horace Danby’. Give a reasoned answer.


Answer : Horace Danby planned to rob the safe at Shotover Grange. He disabled the burglar alarm by cutting its wires. However, the flowers on the table made him sneeze uncontrollably. Suddenly, a young lady dressed in red entered the room. She spoke to Danby in a friendly manner, but her voice was firm. She claimed to be the owner's wife and said she was there to take jewels from the safe for a party that night. She pretended to forget the combination to open the safe. She told the thief she'd let him go if he opened the safe for her. Danby was fooled. He opened the safe without wearing gloves and handed all the jewels to the young lady. She left safely with the jewels, but Danby got caught for the robbery and was sent to prison.
7. What were Horace Danby’s plans for his latest robbery?

Answer : Horace was confident that the robbery he was planning for that year would be just as successful as his previous ones. He had spent two weeks carefully watching and learning about the house at Shotover Grange. He had observed everything minutely. That afternoon, when he planned to rob the house, he had seen the two servants, who remained in the Grange, going to the movies. He came out from behind the garden wall. He packed his tools carefully in a bag on his back. Horace knew there were about fifteen thousand pounds worth of jewels in the Grange safe. He figured if he sold them one by one, he'd have enough money to last him for another year.
8. Horace Danby represents such people who adopt the wrong ways to fulfill their wishes. What values would you like such people to imbibe to reform themselves? Write in about 100-120 words.

Answer : Horace Danby was a successful businessman around fifty years old. He was respected in society, but he had a habit that made him do robberies. Danby had a passion for rare, expensive books, and to obtain them, he would rob a safe every year. Every year, he carefully planned how to get what he wanted. Danby chose the wrong path to fulfill his desires and ended up caught in a plot by a thief like him. It's important for people to learn good values. People should understand that hard work is the main way to succeed. You have to work hard to achieve what you want. I believe people like that should learn honesty, responsibility, hard work, dedication, and self-confidence to change for the better.
9. Horace promised the young lady that he would follow the path of honesty if sills would not hand him over to the police but he could not keep his promise for more than days. Did he lack reconciliation? Was it not in his nature to keep his promise? Did he lack the courage to fulfill his needs through an honest living? Discuss the values he needed to imbibe in 100-120 words.

Answer : The woman cleverly controlled the situation and Horace, skillfully getting the jewels without touching anything. She talked about important things like keeping society safe from people like Horace. Horace promised to be honest and helped her get the jewels by breaking the safe without wearing gloves. But two days later, the police caught him for stealing the jewels. He couldn't make them believe he hadn't taken the jewels and had only helped the owner's wife. This made him break his promise. Even though he truly didn't want to steal anymore, he felt he had no other option.
10. 'He made locks and was successful.' 'a little tickle of hay fever in his nose'. How do these two facts play out for Horace in the story? Do they help him or upset his plans?

Answer : The fact that Horace was in the business of making locks was a big advantage for him as it was easy for him to pick or break locks. He needed to break or pick locks to open safes and steal once a year. This helped him in his plans. The little tickle of hay fever in his nose actually worked to his disadvantage because the sneezing alerted the other thief to his presence and Horace then lost the jewels to the imposter. He was also put behind bars for a crime he did not commit. The hay fever upset his plans.
11. Give a character-sketch of Horace Danby in your own words. How was he outmanoeuvred by the lady in red?

Answer : Horace Danby was around fifty years old and never married. People considered him a good and honest person. Apart from having hay fever in the summer, he was generally healthy and content. He worked as a locksmith and did quite well in his business. While he was good and respected, he wasn't entirely truthful. Every year, he would steal from a safe because he needed money to purchase books. Horace had a strong passion for acquiring rare and expensive books. He used the stolen money to buy the books he adored secretly through an agent.

He prepared meticulously, ensuring each year's robbery would be as successful as the last. He carefully studied the layout of the house at Shotover Grange—its rooms, electric wiring, pathways, and gardens—in great detail. He also came to know that the two servants of the house were out to the movies. He also knew where was safe and it’s key. He befriended the little dog by calling his right name. In spite of all his professionalism, Horace Danby proved a novice in judging the lady in red. The lady in red behaved with so much confidence and authority that Horace became totally a puppet in her hands. The lady in red pretended to be the owner of the house and convinced Horace to open the safe without wearing gloves. While the lady took off with the jewels, Horace was arrested and sent to prison.
12. Horace Danby was a respectable man but he could not be called loyal. What do you think could be the reasons for leading a respectable man like him on the path of thievery? Did he feel a lack of sense of freedom? Was it not in his nature to accept the differences among people regarding their social status? Discuss the values he should have possessed in 100-120 words.

Answer : Horace Danby wasn't like most thieves. He was a respectable man who loved books, but his love for them drove him to steal. He only stole once a year and never took more than he needed. He stole only to buy rare books because he loved them. Also, Danby only robbed wealthy people. It was just how he was. He understood that people had different social statuses. He knew that people from higher social backgrounds could help him get what he wanted, so he found them easy to rob.
13. How had Horace planned to loot the house at Shotover Grange?

Answer : Horace Danby always took his time when stealing. He had succeeded in all his previous thefts. Each year, he robbed a safe, and the money he got lasted him for a year. Just like before, he carefully planned his latest robbery at a house in Shotover Grange, considering every detail. For two weeks, he had been looking closely at the house, its rooms, electric wiring, paths, and garden. He also knew for sure that two servants who worked there had gone to the movies. He saw them leave. He stepped out from behind the garden wall. He had packed his tools carefully in a bag on his back. He had noticed the housekeeper hanging the key to the kitchen door on a hook outside. He put on a pair of gloves, took the key and opened the house. He always put on a pair of gloves before committing a theft. A magazine article had described the house with all the rooms. It also mentioned that a painting hid a safe. He collected all these details and made all preparations to make his latest theft a complete success like the others.
14. Horace stated that he robbed only those who had a lot of money. Was he really a threat to society? Did he lack the qualities of a good citizen? Discuss the values he needs to imbibe to lead a path of righteousness in 100-120 words.

Answer : I don't believe Horace was a danger to society. He never harmed anyone and only stole for a good reason. He would rob a safe each year to afford rare and expensive books for his hobby of reading. He wasn't a professional thief. Furthermore, he never hurt anyone. Everyone thought he was a good and honest person. He was around fifty years old and single. He had all the qualities of a good person in society. He wasn't a criminal or like the usual thief. He only stole to satisfy his need. He was an honest and good person. He trusted the lady's story and gave her all the jewels. If he were a criminal, he would have harmed the lady or kept the jewels for himself.
15. How did the lady in red turn out to be much smarter and cleverer than Horace Danby? How did one thief outwit and out maneuver the other?
Or
How did the lady in red manage to outsmart and out maneuver the other thief, Horace Danby, by robbing the safe without leaving a single fingerprint?


Answer : The lady in red was a thief, just like Horace Danby. But it was she who outsmarted and tricked Horace. Horace did his job very well. He worked hard to gather information about the house's location, the key's position, and the safe. However, Horace wasn't experienced enough to see through the young lady in red. She acted with a lot of confidence and was so convincing that she could easily be mistaken for the lady of the house. Horace Danby was like a puppet controlled by the lady. When caught in the act, he begged her to release him. The young lady took advantage of his confusion and fear of going to prison completely. She made Horace open the safe, tricking him into thinking he was helping the lady of the house. So he opened the safe without wearing gloves and gave the jewels to the lady, leaving his fingerprints behind. That's how he got caught and arrested. The young lady in red proved to be much smarter and outsmarted Horace Danby.
Extract Based Question -1

Read the following extracts carefully and answer the questions that follow.

For two weeks he had been studying the house at Shotover Grange, looking at its rooms, its electric wiring, its paths and its garden. This afternoon the two servants, who remained in the Grange while the family was in London, had gone to the movies. Horace saw them go, and he felt happy in spite of a little tickle of hay fever in his nose. He came out from behind the garden wall, his tools were carefullypacked in a bag on his back.

1. What was Horace Danby doing for two weeks before the incident at Shotover Grange?
A) Studying the electric wiring of the house
B) Watching movies with the servants
C) Planning a burglary
D) Tending to the garden
Answer : C) Planning a burglary

2. What were the two servants doing while Horace Danby was studying the house?
A) Watching movies
B) Attending a party
C) Sleeping
D) Going to London
Answer : A) Watching movies

3. How did Horace feel when he saw the servants leave the house?
A) Anxious
B) Happy
C) Frightened
D) Bored
Answer : B) Happy

4. What was bothering Horace Danby as he entered the house?
A) His allergies
B) Fear of being caught
C) Noise from the movie theater
D) Doubt about his plan
Answer : A) His allergies

5. Where did Horace keep his tools for the burglary?
A) In his hand
B) In a bag on his back
C) In the garden
D) In the kitchen
Answer : B) In a bag on his back

6. What was Horace's primary goal when he entered Shotover Grange?
A) To watch a movie
B) To meet the servants
C) To steal jewels
D) To tend to the garden
Answer : C) To steal jewels

7. Why did Horace feel happy despite his allergies?
A) He enjoyed studying the house
B) He found a bag of tools
C) The servants left the house
D) He saw a movie
Answer : C) The servants left the house

8. What did Horace see in the house's drawing room?
A) A painting
B) A safe
C) A vase of flowers
D) A dog
Answer : C) A vase of flowers

9. What was Horace's physical reaction to the flowers in the drawing room?
A) He smiled
B) He sneezed
C) He laughed
D) He cried
Answer : B) He sneezed

10. What was the immediate consequence of Horace cutting the burglar alarm?
A) The police arrived
B) The lights went out
C) The dog barked
D) A young lady appeared
Answer : D) A young lady appeared
Extract Based Question -2

Read the following extracts carefully and answer the questions that follow.

“He made locks and was successful enough at his business to have two helpers. Yes, Horace Danby was good and respectable — but not completely honest. Fifteen years ago, Horace had served his first and only sentence in a prison library. He loved rare, expensive books. So he robbed a safe every year. Each year he planned carefully just what he would do, stole enough to last for twelve months, and secretly bought the books he loved through an agent.”

1. What was Horace Danby's profession?

A) Locksmith
B) Librarian
C) Detective
D) Businessman
Answer : A) Locksmith

2. How many helpers did Horace Danby have in his business?

A) None
B) One
C) Two
D) Three
Answer : C) Two

3. What aspect of Horace Danby's character is highlighted as not completely honest?

A) His business dealings
B) His appearance
C) His personal life
D) His criminal activities
Answer : D) His criminal activities

4. How long ago did Horace serve his first and only sentence in a prison library?

A) Ten years ago
B) Fifteen years ago
C) Twenty years ago
D) Five years ago
Answer : B) Fifteen years ago

5. What was Horace's motivation for committing burglary?

A) To buy rare books
B) To support his family
C) To fund his business
D) To travel the world
Answer : A) To buy rare books

6. How often did Horace Danby rob a safe?

A) Monthly
B) Quarterly
C) Annually
D) Biannually
Answer : C) Annually

7. How did Horace Danby procure the books he loved after committing burglary?

A) He stole them from libraries
B) He bought them openly
C) He secretly purchased them through an agent
D) He borrowed them from friends
Answer : C) He secretly purchased them through an agent

8. What was Horace Danby's reputation in the community?

A) Completely honest
B) Disreputable
C) Respected but not completely honest
D) Unknown
Answer : C) Respected but not completely honest

9. How did Horace plan his burglaries?

A) Impulsively
B) Carefully
C) Recklessly
D) Haphazardly
Answer : B) Carefully

10. What was the consequence of Horace Danby's criminal activities?

A) He became a wealthy man
B) He was caught and imprisoned
C) He gained notoriety
D) He lived a life of luxury
Answer : B) He was caught and imprisoned
Read and Find Out

1. What does Horace Danby like to collect?
Answer : Horace Danby likes to collect rare, expensive books. He steals once a year to fund his passion for buying these books through an agent.

2. Why does he steal every year?
Answer : Horace Danby steals every year to buy rare and expensive books. He carefully plans and executes a robbery once a year, stealing enough to last for twelve months, so he can secretly purchase the books he loves through an agent.
Read and Find Out

1. Who is speaking to Horace Danby?
Answer : A young, pretty woman dressed in red is speaking to Horace Danby. She pretends to be the owner of the house and tricks him into opening the safe for her. In reality, she is also a thief who deceives Horace and escapes with the jewels, leaving him to take the blame.

2. Who is the real culprit in the story?
Answer : The real culprit in the story is the young woman in red who tricks Horace Danby. She pretends to be the owner of the house and manipulates him into opening the safe for her. After taking the jewels, she disappears, leaving Horace to be caught and arrested for the robbery.
Think About it

1. Did you begin to suspect, before the end of the story, that the lady was not the person Horace Danby took her to be? If so, at what point did you realise this, and how?
Answer : Yes, there are subtle hints in the story that suggest the lady might not be who she claims to be. The first sign of suspicion arises when she appears unexpectedly and shows no fear upon seeing a burglar in her house. Instead of being alarmed, she remains calm, speaks confidently, and even amuses herself with Horace’s predicament.

Another clue is how easily she manipulates Horace, playing on his fear of getting caught and convincing him to open the safe for her. The biggest red flag is when she claims to have forgotten the combination to the safe, which seems unlikely for the owner of valuable jewels.

The final confirmation comes when Horace is arrested, and the actual lady of the house is revealed to be a much older woman, proving that the young woman in red was an impostor and the true thief.

2. What are the subtle ways in which the lady manages to deceive Horace Danby into thinking she is the lady of the house? Why doesn’t Horace suspect that something is wrong?
Answer : The lady deceives Horace Danby in several subtle ways:

Calm and Confident Behavior – Instead of panicking upon seeing a burglar, she remains composed, speaks firmly, and takes control of the situation. Her confidence makes Horace believe she is the rightful owner.

Knowledge of the House – She interacts with the dog, Sherry, in a familiar way and even adjusts ornaments on the fireplace, as if she truly belongs there. This convinces Horace that she lives in the house.

Manipulative Language – She smoothly leads the conversation, acting amused rather than threatened. She makes Horace feel guilty and plays on his emotions, making him eager to gain her favor.

Fake Problem-Solving Approach – She pretends she needs his help to open the safe, claiming she forgot the combination. This clever trick makes Horace feel useful and lowers his guard.

Horace doesn’t suspect anything because:
He is flustered by his hay fever and the unexpected encounter.

He is eager to escape trouble and believes she might let him go if he cooperates.

He underestimates the possibility of being tricked, as he thinks he is the only thief in the house.

His desperation to avoid getting caught blinds him to the deception, leading to his downfall.

3. “Horace Danby was good and respectable — but not completely honest”. Why do you think this description is apt for Horace? Why can’t he be categorised as a typical thief?
Answer : The description “Horace Danby was good and respectable — but not completely honest” fits him well because, on the surface, he appears to be an upright citizen. He is a successful locksmith, well-respected in society, and leads a quiet life. However, his one flaw is that he commits a burglary once a year—not out of greed, but to buy rare and expensive books that he loves. He carefully plans his thefts, ensuring that he only steals from the wealthy and avoids harming anyone. This duality in his character makes him both respectable and dishonest at the same time.

Horace cannot be categorized as a typical thief because he does not steal for survival or luxury, but for his passion. Unlike hardened criminals, he is meticulous, polite, and even fearful of getting caught. His downfall comes not from a lack of skill, but from being outwitted by a more cunning thief—the woman in red. His naïve belief in honor among thieves ultimately leads to his arrest, proving that while he was a thief, he was not ruthless or deceptive enough to survive in the world of crime.

4. Horace Danby was a meticulous planner but still he faltered. Where did he go wrong and why?
Answer : Horace Danby was a meticulous planner who carefully studied his targets before committing a robbery. He spent weeks observing the house, learning about its wiring, security, and the movements of the servants. He even took precautions like wearing gloves to avoid leaving fingerprints. However, he made a crucial mistake when he let his guard down upon meeting the young woman in red. Instead of questioning her identity, he was easily manipulated into believing she was the lady of the house. His fear of being caught and his eagerness to please her clouded his judgment, leading him to open the safe without gloves.

His biggest failure was trusting someone without verifying her identity. As a seasoned thief, he should have been suspicious of the woman’s sudden appearance and her unusual request. However, he was too focused on escaping trouble and overlooked obvious red flags, such as her calm demeanor and her claim of forgetting the safe’s combination. By not following his usual careful approach, he left his fingerprints on the safe, which ultimately led to his arrest. His downfall was not due to a flaw in his planning but rather his overconfidence and emotional vulnerability, which made him an easy target for deception.
Talk About it

1. Do you think Horace Danby was unfairly punished, or that he deserved what he got?

Answer : Horace Danby deserved his punishment because stealing is a crime, no matter the reason. Even though he only stole once a year for books, he still broke the law. However, it was unfair that he got caught while the real thief, the woman in red, escaped. He was tricked, but his mistake of leaving fingerprints led to his arrest. In the end, his carelessness cost him his freedom.

2. Do intentions justify actions? Would you, like Horace Danby, do something wrong if you thought your ends justified the means? Do you think that there are situations in which it is excusable to act less than honestly?

Answer : Intentions do not always justify actions because doing something wrong, even for a good reason, can still cause harm. Like Horace Danby, some people might believe their reasons make their actions acceptable, but stealing is still a crime. However, in certain situations, like helping someone in danger or survival needs, acting less than honestly might be excusable. It depends on the situation and whether the action causes harm to others.

Practice MCQs

39 multiple-choice questions on A Question of Trust. Tap an option to check the answer.

Q. 1
What was Horace Danby doing for two weeks before the incident at Shotover Grange?
A
Studying the electric wiring of the house
B
Watching movies with the servants
C
Planning a burglary
D
Tending to the garden
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 2
What were the two servants doing while Horace Danby was studying the house?
A
Watching movies
B
Attending a party
C
Sleeping
D
Going to London
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 3
How did Horace feel when he saw the servants leave the house?
A
Anxious
B
Happy
C
Frightened
D
Bored
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 4
What was bothering Horace Danby as he entered the house?
A
Doubt about his plan
B
Noise from the movie theater
C
Fear of being caught
D
His allergies
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 5
Where did Horace keep his tools for the burglary?
A
In his hand
B
In the garden
C
In a bag on his back
D
In the kitchen
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 6
What was Horace's primary goal when he entered Shotover Grange?
A
To watch a movie
B
To meet the servants
C
To steal jewels
D
To tend to the garden
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 7
Why did Horace feel happy despite his allergies?
A
He saw a movie
B
The servants left the house
C
He found a bag of tools
D
He enjoyed studying the house
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 8
What did Horace see in the house's drawing room?
A
A vase of flowers
B
A dog
C
A safe
D
A painting
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 9
What was Horace's physical reaction to the flowers in the drawing room?
A
He sneezed
B
He smiled
C
He laughed
D
He cried
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 10
What was the immediate consequence of Horace cutting the burglar alarm?
A
The police arrived
B
The lights went out
C
The dog barked
D
A young lady appeared
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 11
What was Horace Danby's profession?
A
Locksmith
B
Detective
C
Librarian
D
Businessman
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 12
How many helpers did Horace Danby have in his business?
A
None
B
One
C
Two
D
Three
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 13
What aspect of Horace Danby's character is highlighted as not completely honest?
A
His business dealings
B
His personal life
C
His appearance
D
His criminal activities
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 14
How long ago did Horace serve his first and only sentence in a prison library?
A
Ten years ago
B
Fifteen years ago
C
Twenty years ago
D
Five years ago
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 15
What was Horace's motivation for committing burglary?
A
To buy rare books
B
To support his family
C
To fund his business
D
To travel the world
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 16
How often did Horace Danby rob a safe?
A
Monthly
B
Quarterly
C
Annually
D
Biannually
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 17
How did Horace Danby procure the books he loved after committing burglary?
A
He stole them from libraries
B
He bought them openly
C
He secretly purchased them through an agent
D
He borrowed them from friends
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 18
What was Horace Danby's reputation in the community?
A
Unknown
B
Respected but not completely honest
C
Disreputable
D
Completely honest
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 19
How did Horace plan his burglaries?
A
Carefully
B
Recklessly
C
Impulsively
D
Haphazardly
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 20
What was the consequence of Horace Danby's criminal activities?
A
He became a wealthy man
B
He gained notoriety
C
He lived a life of luxury
D
He was caught and imprisoned
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 21
The lady in red said, 'Society must be protected by men like you.' Here, men like you means:
A
ill-men like Horace.
B
robbers like Horace.
C
respectable men like Horace.
D
businessmen like Horace.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 22
Choose the character traits of the lady in red as demonstrated by her in the story.
(1) an unscrupulous thief
(2) confident and bold
(3) naive
(4) shrewd

A
Options 1, 2 and 3
B
Options 1, 2 and 4
C
Option 2 only
D
Option 3 only
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 23
Choose the character traits of Horace as demonstrated in the story.
(1) meticulous planner
(2) honest
(3) respectable
(4) easily befooled

A
Options 1, 2 and 3
B
Option 1 only
C
Options 1, 3 and 4
D
Options 2, 3 and 4
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 24
The lady in red had a plan in her mind. What was it?
A
She planned to go to a party.
B
She planned to dupe Horace.
C
She planned to walk the dog.
D
She had a plan to stay in her house.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 25
After all, he had lived with locks and safes all his life, this statement infers that Horace:
A
always lived in a locked room.
B
was an expert at opening locks and safes.
C
had been a professional robber.
D
had always got imprisonment.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 26
What was the promise that Horace made to the 'lady in red'?
A
He will never commit robbery again.
B
He will open the safe for her.
C
He will not tell anything about the opening of safe to her husband.
D
He will help her whenever she needs.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 27
Horace Danby is described as good and respectable but not completely honest'. This shows that Horace was_______ .
A
a respectable man but a thief.
B
a man of bad reputation.
C
an unsuccessful man but respected by all.
D
a professional robber.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 28
Horace planned the robbery at Shotover Grange in spite of having "a little tickle of hay fever" in his nose due to which Horace felt a little________ .
A
insecure
B
excited
C
terrified
D
uneasy
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 29
When the lady in red said, 'However, I came back just in time, though I didn't expect to meet burglar,' her tone was:
A
Kind and quiet
B
Firm and surprised
C
Angry and complaining
D
Nice and warm
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 30
Choose the option which is NOT the meaning of the word 'hindrance'.
A
stop
B
fragrance
C
interfere
D
hold back
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 31
Horace covered his face with a handkerchief because:
A
it was cold there.
B
he wanted to stop coughing.
C
Horace feared an attack of hay fever.
D
he hid his face in shame.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 32
Why was Horace Danby compelled to commit robbery every year to steal enough money?
A
To maintain his status of a respectable man.
B
To run his business successfully.
C
To survive for the entire year.
D
To fulfill his hobby of collecting rare and expensive books.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 33
Horace took off his gloves to light the cigarette of the 'lady in red'. His action shows that:
A
he got terrified by the presence of the lady.
B
he did not feel like wearing them.
C
he found it difficult to lit the lighter with gloves on.
D
he became careless about his security.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 34
The dog, Sherry, was rubbing against the lady in red, it shows that:
A
The dog was showing its resentment.
B
the dog was trying to clean itself.
C
the dog had an acquaintance with the lady.
D
the lady offered a bone to the dog.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 35
The owners of Shotover Grange are called foolish because:
A
a magazine had published where the safe was kept.
B
they had not given the code to open the safe in a magazine.
C
they had not kept the safe locked.
D
they left the house unlocked.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 36
'Horace had some hope because she seemed to be amused at meeting him' What hope did Horace have?
A
He will be successful in his task of robbery.
B
The lady will be friendly with him.
C
The lady will let him go.
D
He will be welcomed by the lady.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 37
Which one of the following statements is NOT TRUE according to the chapter?
A
She was not in her own house.
B
The lady had been away for a month.
C
She was a clever person.
D
She was talking to a burglar.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 38
Which of the following describes the phrase 'honour among thieves'?
A
Thieving should be considered as an honourable profession.
B
Thieves must be honoured.
C
Thieves must give honour to each other.
D
Thieves must be honest to each other.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 39
The article in the magazine said 'a painting hid a safe' this line means that
A
there was a safety lock on the expensive painting.
B
there was a safe in the painting.
C
the safe had precious things to hide.
D
the painting was kept safely
Click an option to check your answer