The Making of a Scientist

20 questionsCBSE 2027
10 min read
Share:

Study Notes

THE MAKING OF A SCIENTIST
SUMMARY

"The Making of a Scientist" was written by Robert W. Peterson. It tells the story of Richard Ebright, a famous scientist who was curious and smart since he was very young. He loved collecting butterflies, and by the time he was in second grade, he had already collected 25 different kinds of butterflies in his hometown. His mother always supported his interests and gave him a book called "The Travels of Monarch X" as a gift.

The book changed Richard's life by introducing him to the wonders of science. It showed him how monarch butterflies travel to Central America, sparking his curiosity to learn more about these creatures. Inspired, he entered the county science fair, realizing he needed to do something impressive. He kept working hard until he succeeded in showcasing his experiments and earning a spot at the fair.

In his eighth-grade project, Richard aimed to find out what was making many monarch caterpillars sick each year. He thought a beetle might be spreading the sickness, so he raised caterpillars alongside beetles to test his idea. But the experiment didn't give him any clear answers. Still, he showed his project at the county science fair and ended up winning that year's competition.

In his sophomore year of high school, Richard began researching a mysterious hormone in insects, which led to a new theory about cell life. He focused on figuring out the purpose of twelve small golden spots on a monarch butterfly pupa. His project won top prize at a county science fair, earning him a chance to work at the entomology lab at the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research.

When Richard was in his second year of high school, he started studying a strange hormone in insects. This led to a new idea about how cells work. He wanted to understand why there were twelve little golden spots on a monarch butterfly's pupa. His project won first place in a science fair, and he got to work at a lab that studies insects at the Walter Reed Army Institute of Research.

In college, Richard Ebright and his roommate James R. Wong worked tirelessly, drawing pictures and making models to explain how DNA functions. This was a big step forward for Ebright, who graduated from Harvard with top honors, ranking second out of 1,510 students. His research was even published in a science magazine. After graduation, he became a researcher at Harvard Medical School, where he continued his experiments.

In high school, Richard Ebright excelled academically, getting top grades. He also enjoyed debate, public speaking, and outdoor activities like canoeing. He was competitive and always gave his best effort in everything he did. Overall, he had all the qualities of a great scientist: intelligence, curiosity, determination, and a sense of doing what's right.
SHORT ANSWER TYPES QUESTION (SAQ)
1. How did Ebright raise a flock of butterflies?

Answer : Ebright would catch a female monarch and take her eggs. He would raise them in his basement, from egg to caterpillar, pupa to adult butterfly. Then he would tag the butterflies "s" and release them.
2. Why did Ebright begin to lose interest in tagging butterflies?

Answer : Ebright started to get less interested in tagging butterflies because he didn't get any feedback. He felt disappointed because only two butterflies had been found again, and they weren't far from where he lived, within seventy-five miles.
3. Comment on the role of Mr. Weathered in Albright’s life,
Or
Who were the important people in Albright’s life? Why


Answer : The important people in Ebright's life were his mom, who encouraged him to be curious and love learning since he was young, and Dr. Frederick A. Urquhart, who inspired him to study butterflies. Also, Mr. Weathered, Ebright's Social Studies teacher, opened his mind to new ideas and praised him for working hard and never giving up.
4. What were the factors which contributed to making Ebright a scientist?
Or
What are the essential qualities for becoming a scientist, according to Albright’s teacher?


Answer : To become a scientist, you need to be smart, really interested in your topic, and determined to do what's right. You shouldn't just chase after awards, but you should have a competitive spirit, as long as it's not in a negative way.
5. What all hobbies did Albright develop in kindergarten?

Answer : As a kid, Ebright was really curious and loved learning. He did well in school and got the best grades. He enjoyed collecting rocks, fossils, and coins, and he was also really interested in astronomy.
6. Which book did Ebright’s mother give him? How did this book change his life?

Answer : One day, Ebright's mom gave him a kids' book called "The Travels of Monarch X." It talked about how monarch butterflies fly to Central America. He loved this book and it made him really interested in butterflies. He spent a lot of time studying them and won lots of awards. So, this book really changed his life.
7. ”Science shows a connection between structure and function.” Show this to be so, for the spots Albright saw on Monarch pupas.

Answer : Ebright grew cells from a monarch butterfly's wing to demonstrate that they could grow into normal wing scales only when given the hormones from the gold spots. Later, he figured out the chemical structure of the hormone and learned how cells can understand DNA instructions.
8. Which project of Ebright won first prize in the county science fair?

Answer : At his first science fair, Ebright didn't win anything, which made him realize that actual experiments were important. Afterwards, he began winning prizes. Ebright and his scientist friend built a device that proved the tiny gold spots on a monarch pupa were making a hormone needed for the butterfly to grow properly. Their project won the first prize at the local science fair and came in third for zoology at the international science fair.
9. How can Albright’s theory of cell life be a revolution in the medical field if it is proved correct?

Answer : Ebright figured out what the gold spot hormone was made of and how cells can understand DNA instructions. To check if his idea was right, he started doing experiments. If it turns out to be true, it will be a big move toward understanding how life works. It could give us new ideas for stopping certain cancers and diseases.
10. Why did Richard Ebright tag a flock of butterflies?
Or
Why did Richard Ebright start a project of tagging the butterflies?


Answer : Once, Ebright's mother bought him a book called "The Travels of Monarch X". At the end of the book, Dr. A. Urquhart asked readers to help him study butterfly migration by tagging them. So, Ebright began tagging butterflies.
11. What made in light straight. A grade pit dint in it-hoot?

Answer : Richard loved being outside, taking pictures, and learning about nature. He was really good at studying insects, like monarch butterflies, and he knew a lot about DNA too. Because he was so dedicated and interested in many things, he got top grades in school.
12. How did Richard’s mother helped him to become a scientist?
Or
How did Ebright’s mother help in his learning?


Answer : Ebright was very curious and smart, which are important qualities for being a scientist. His mother motivated him to keep learning. She showed him the world by taking him on trips and buying him books, telescopes, microscopes, cameras, and other tools. These things helped him learn.
13. Why did Ebright lose interest in tagging butterflies?

Answer : Ebright's interest in tagging butterflies faded because it was repetitive work and didn't show important results or feedback, which made him lose interest in doing it.
14. Identify four values which Richard Ebright projected as a man of substance.

Answer : Ebright wasn't just a great scientist, he was also very observant. He excelled in sea champion debates and public speaking. He was skilled at photography, especially of nature and scientific displays.
15. Which project did Ebright submit in his eighth grade? Why did he win?

Answer : In eighth grade, Richard Ebright decided to investigate why a virus was causing the deaths of monarch caterpillars. He tried raising caterpillars alongside beetles, thinking the beetles might be spreading the virus, but it didn't give him any clear answers. Despite this setback, he didn't give up. He presented his experiments and efforts anyway, and his hard work paid off when he won a prize for his dedication and initiative.
16. "Richard was the focus of his mother’s attention." Compose a thesis on this.

Answer : Richard's dad died when he was three, so his mom focused all her attention on him. This close relationship and supportive environment made him interested in learning, which helped him succeed in different areas, like science.
17. What did Ebright realize when he started tagging butterflies?

Answer : Ebright began putting tags on monarch butterflies. He noticed that trying to catch them one by one wasn't very effective. So, he decided to raise a group of butterflies instead.
18. To which field of science has Richard H. Ebright contributed?

Answer : Richard H. Ebright is a top scientist who has been interested in science since he was a boy. He has made big contributions to biochemistry and molecular biology.
19. What were their hobbies of Ebright in his childhood?

Answer : Ebright loved collecting stuff. He was really into butterflies and started collecting them when he was in kindergarten. He also liked collecting rocks, fossils, and coins. Plus, he enjoyed looking at the stars and learning about astronomy.
20. How did Ebright’s mother help him in his hunger for learning?

Answer : Ebright's mom always gave him things to do if he was bored. She gave him tasks to learn from. He really loved learning and got the best grades in school. By the time he was in second grade, he had gathered 25 types of butterflies.
21. Describe Richard Ebright’s childhood.
Or
How did Ebright spend his time in Pennsylvania?


Answer : Ebright lived north of Reading, Pennsylvania when he was growing up. He was his parents' only child. His dad passed away when he was in third grade. He did really well in school and liked collecting rocks, fossils, and coins when he was a kid.
22. How and where did Richard Ebright identify the hormone’s chemical structure?

Answer : After completing his first year at Harvard University, Ebright returned to the Department of Agriculture's laboratory. He continued studying the hormones of the gold spots. With advanced tools available, he managed to figure out the chemical structure of the hormone.
23. How did the hook become a turning point in Richard Ebright’s life?

Answer : One time, his mother bought him the book 'The Travels of Monarch X'. At the end of the book, Dr. A. Urquhart asked people to help him study how monarch butterflies move by tagging them. This changed his life.
24. What did Ebright discover about the spots on a monarch butterfly’s pupa?

Answer : Ebright wanted to know why monarch butterfly pupae had twelve tiny gold spots. To find out, he and another student built a device. It showed that these spots produce a hormone essential for the butterfly's complete development.
25. What idea did Ebright get when he was looking at the X-ray photos of cells?

Answer : One day, Ebright looked at X-ray pictures of cell chemical structures. He came up with a new idea about how cells work. Those pictures helped him solve a puzzle in biology: how cells can understand DNA instructions.
26. What did Ebright realize when he did not win any prize at the county science fair?

Answer : He realized that the winners had tried to do real experiments. So he decided to do further research in his favourite field, that is, insects, on which he had already been doing work.
27. How did Richard Ebright give an answer to one of biology’s puzzles—how the cell can read the blueprint of its DNA?

Answer : When Richard Ebright saw X-ray pictures of the chemical structure of a hormone, he didn't shout, "Eureka!" or say, "I've got it!" Instead, he was confident that the photos provided the solution to one of biology's mysteries. He had discovered how cells could understand the instructions in their DNA, which is the substance in a cell's nucleus that controls traits passed down from parents. DNA acts as the blueprint for life.
28. How did Ebright’s basement become home to thousands of monarch butterflies?

Answer : Richard Ebright sent monarch butterflies with tags to Dr. Urquhart for research. Since catching them one by one was too hard, he decided to rear some in his basement. Here's what he did: He'd catch a monarch butterfly, collect its eggs, and carefully raise them. Once they turned into butterflies, he tagged their wings before setting them free. Over time, his basement became a sanctuary for thousands of monarch butterflies.
29. What happened when Ebright wrote to Dr. Urquhart for ideas?

Answer : Ebright wrote to Dr. Urquhart asking for ideas. Dr. Urquhart, a famous scientist, gave him lots of suggestions for experiments. These experiments kept Ebright busy throughout high school. He also won many awards at local and international science fairs.
30. What lessons did Richard Ebright learn when he didn’t win anything at the County Science Fair?

Answer : In seventh grade, Richard Ebright entered his first project in the County Science Fair. While everyone else won something, he came back with nothing. It was a really sad experience for him. His loss taught him a valuable lesson. He understood that to succeed, he needed to conduct real experiments. Just showing slides of frog tissues under a microscope wasn't enough. Real science meant doing actual experiments.
31. Mention any two of Ebright’s contributions to the world of science.

Answer : He did experiments that showed the hormone made by the gold spots on a pupa helps the wings of a butterfly grow and form properly. He also found out how a cell can understand the DNA instructions that control traits passed down from parents.
32. What happened with Ebright when he entered a county science fair for the first time?

Answer : He entered a county science fair in Ebright for the first time. His entries were slides of frog tissues. But he did not win any prizes.
33. Which simple question led to the discovery of an unknown insect hormone?

Answer : In his second year in high school, Ebright’s research led to his discovery of an unknown insect hormone. Indirectly, it led to his new theory on the life of cells. He tried to answer a very simple question: “What is the purpose of the twelve tiny gold spots on a monarch pupa?"
34. Richard Ebright was a famous scientist but he had time for other interests too. What were the other interests and hobbies of Ebright?

Answer : Richard Ebright began his journey as a scientist by collecting butterflies. But he also enjoyed other hobbies. He was a skilled debater and speaker, and he was great at canoeing. Additionally, he was an expert photographer, especially when it came to capturing nature and scientific displays.
35. How did Richard Ebright excite the scientific world at the age of twenty-two?

Answer : Richard Ebright was only twenty-two when he amazed the scientific community with a new idea about how cells functioned. He and his college roommate wrote about the theory in a paper for the 'Proceedings of the National Academy of Science'. This was the first time this respected scientific journal had published the work of college students.
36. “There was one thing I could do —collect things.” What did Richard Ebright do in his childhood?

Answer : Richard Ebright was an only child. He didn't have much to do where he lived, but he found one thing he could do - collect things. So, he started collecting butterflies when he was in kindergarten. By the time he was in second grade, he had collected all 25 kinds of butterflies that lived near his home. He also collected rocks, fossils, and coins. Sometimes, he spent the whole night looking at the stars.
37. Why do viceroy butterflies copy monarch butterflies? What reasons did Richard Ebright give in this regard?

Answer : Richard Ebright had a project to test if viceroy butterflies imitated monarch butterflies. Viceroys looked similar to monarchs because monarchs weren't tasty to birds. Viceroy butterflies taste good to birds, unlike monarch butterflies. To stay safe, they mimic the appearance of monarch butterflies.
38. How did Richard Ebright’s mother be a source of inspiration and encouragement in his quest for learning?

Answer : Richard Ebright was lucky because his mother was very supportive and encouraging. Since he lost his father early, his mother made up for it by being there for him. She supported his interest in learning by taking him on trips and buying him tools like telescopes, microscopes, cameras, and other stuff he needed. She also helped him find work and taught him many things in different ways.
39. What book opened the world of science to the eager young collector, Richard Ebright?

Answer : Richard Ebright loved collecting stuff. When he was in second grade, he had gathered all 25 types of butterflies from his hometown. The book that really got him interested in science was called "The Travels of Monarch X." His mom gave it to him as a gift. It was a kids' book that talked about how monarch butterflies traveled to Central America.
40. Why and where did Richard Ebright send the tagged butterflies?

Answer : At the end of "The Travels of Monarch X," readers were asked to help with studying monarch butterfly migration. They were invited to put small stickers on the wings of butterflies for Dr. Urquhart's research. Richard Ebright started attaching these tags to monarch butterflies and sent them to Dr. Urquhart for his studies.
41. When and how did Richard Ebright get a hint of what real science is?

Answer : In seventh grade, Richard Ebright got a taste of true science when he entered a county science fair. Unfortunately, he lost and felt really down because everyone else won. He had submitted slides of frog tissues that he observed under a microscope. He understood that the winners had conducted actual experiments, while he only created a nice presentation without any real experimentation.
42. Who was Dr. Frederick A Urquhart? Why did Richard Ebright look to him for fresh ideas?

Answer : Dr. Frederick A. Urquhart was a scientist and teacher at the University of Toronto in Canada. He studied butterfly migrations. Ebright sent him lots of butterflies with tags for his research. Richard Ebright sought his advice and ideas. Dr. Urquhart gave Richard Ebright many ideas for experiments. These ideas helped him win lots of prizes in County and International Science Fairs.
43. “Richie was my whole life after his father died …,” said Richard’s mother. Describe Richard Ebright’s relationship with his mother.

Answer : Richard was in third grade when his father died. He was her mother’s whole life and her only companion until he started school. She and Richard spent almost every evening at the dining table. She found work for him and Richard wanted to learn. His mother encouraged his interest in learning.
44. Were twelve tiny gold spots on a monarch pupa just ornamental? What did Richard Ebright prove in this regard? What honours did this project bring to Richard Ebright?

Answer : Many people thought the twelve gold spots on a monarch pupa were just for decoration. But Dr. Urquhart disagreed. Richard made a device that proved the spots were producing an important hormone. This hormone was crucial for the butterfly's proper development. This project won Ebright first place in the county fair and an entry into the International Science and Engineering Fair.
45. Why do the viceroy butterflies imitate the monarch butterflies?

Answer : In one of his science fair projects, he checked if viceroy butterflies copy monarchs. He found that viceroys look like monarchs because birds don't like to eat monarchs. Instead, they prefer to eat viceroy butterflies. So, by looking like monarchs, viceroys avoid being eaten by birds.
46. How did Richard Ebright grow cells from a monarch butterfly’s wing? What did that project win for Ebright?

Answer : Richard Ebright kept going with his journey. He grew cells from a monarch butterfly's wing in a special environment. He proved that these cells could divide and turn into normal butterfly wing scales. They needed to be nourished by the hormone produced by the gold spots. This project earned him first place in zoology at the International Fair.
LONG ANSWER TYPES QUESTION (LAQ)
1. How did The Travels of Monarch X open the world of science to Richard Ebright? Elaborate.

Answer : i.The book "The Travels of Monarch X" completely changed Richard Ebright's life. It talked about how monarch butterflies fly to Central America. Richard Ebright really loved collecting things and was very enthusiastic.

ii. When he was in second grade, Richard Ebright had collected all 25 types of butterflies from his hometown. If he hadn't received "The Travels of Monarch X," he might have stopped collecting butterflies. The book was for kids and was given to him by his mom.

iii. At the end of the book, readers were invited to help study butterfly migrations. They were asked to tag butterflies for research by Dr. Urquhart. Soon, Ebright started sending tagged butterflies to Dr. Urquhart of the University of Toronto, Canada.

iv. After that, Ebright began raising many butterflies in his basement. For several years, his basement was full of thousands of monarch butterflies at different stages of growth.

v. Dr. Urquhart had a big impact on Richard Ebright's life. He had Ebright do detailed experiments on monarch butterflies. Ebright proved that viceroy butterflies imitate monarchs to avoid being eaten by birds. He also explained how DNA controls traits passed down and is like a blueprint for life.
2. Give a brief character sketch of Ebright's mother.

Answer : Richard H. Ebright's mother was an important driving force behind him who laid the foundation of his success. Ebright was her only child whom she affectionately called 'Richie'. After her husband's death, her son who was in third grade, was her whole life. She would encourage his interest in learning and would take him to trips, buy him telescopes, microscopes, cameras, mounting materials, and other equipments. She was his only companion until he started school. After that, she would bring home his friends for him and at night be with him to do things together. She would spend almost every evening at the dining room table with her son 'Richie'. When he did not have things to do, she would find work for him that would help him learn things. This support, guidance, care and concern of Ebright's mother, helped the growth of a curious child into an accomplished scientist.
3. How did Ebright’s mother encourage him to become a scientist?

Answer : i. Ebright's mom noticed his curiosity and supported him. She took him on trips and bought him tools like telescopes, microscopes, cameras, and other gear for his hobbies.

ii. Ebright's mom was his friend until he began attending school. She would bring home friends for him. Ebright’s mother would find work for him if he had nothing to do. She found learning tasks for him.

iii. He really loved learning and got the best grades in school. When he was in second grade, he had already collected 25 types of butterflies. One day, his mother gave him a children's book that introduced him to science.
4. How did Ebright discover an unknown insect hormone?

Answer : i. During his second year of high school, Ebright's research led to him finding a new insect hormone. This discovery indirectly led to his new theory about how cells function.

ii. He wanted to answer a simple question: Why are there twelve small gold spots on a monarch pupa? To prove his point, Ebright and another student made a device that showed the spots were making a hormone.

iii. The hormone was needed for the butterfly to grow properly. This project earned Ebright first prize in the county fair and a spot in the International Science and Engineering Fair. He got third place there for zoology.
5. How does Richard Ebright become a scientist?

Answer : i. Richard Ebright started on his journey to become a scientist when he was young, because he was naturally curious and his mom supported him. Even when he was in kindergarten, he liked collecting rocks, fossils, coins, and butterflies, showing how much he liked nature.

ii. As Richard Ebright got older, he became even more interested in science. He got a chance to follow his scientific interests when Dr. Frederick A. Urquhart asked him to help collect butterflies for research. This experience made Ebright really interested in doing scientific research.

iii. In seventh grade, Ebright entered a county science fair and experienced a significant setback. He realized that real science was not just about creating a neat display, but conducting experiments that provided insight into scientific phenomena. This realization inspired him to work harder on his science projects in school.

iv.Ebright's efforts paid off when he came in first at a county fair, earning him a spot in the international science and engineering fair. Although he only got third place there, it encouraged him even more to follow his passion for scientific research.

v. Ebright continued his scientific pursuits in high school and conducted research on the purpose of the spots on a Monarch pupa. This research eventually led him to develop his theory about cell life, which would become a significant contribution to the scientific community.

vi. Ebright became a famous scientist because he was curious, worked hard, and loved science. His journey shows how important it is to stay curious, find opportunities, keep trying after failures, and pursue your interests to succeed in science.
6. How did Ebright get the idea for his new theory about cell life? How can this theory be beneficial?

Answer : i. One day, Ebright looked at X-ray pictures of cell chemical structures. This gave him an idea for his new theory about how cells work. The photos helped him solve a biology puzzle: how cells understand the instructions in their DNA.

ii. DNA is like a recipe book inside a cell's nucleus that controls what traits you inherit. It's like the blueprint for life. Ebright and his college roommate James R. Wong drew pictures and made plastic models of molecules to explain how it works.

iii. At Harvard Medical School, Ebright started testing his theory through experiments. If the theory turns out to be right, it could be a major step in understanding how life works. It might also give us new ideas for stopping certain cancers and other diseases.
7. Give a character sketch of Richard Ebright highlighting his achievements and his added interests.

Answer : i. Richard H. Ebright was incredibly skilled and versatile. He excelled as a scientist, a devoted son, and a respectful student. He had a wide range of interests and hobbies. However, above all, he was recognized primarily as a scientist. His fame and recognition came from his remarkable achievements and contributions to the study of butterflies.

ii. When Ebright was in second grade, he collected all 25 kinds of butterflies from his hometown. Ebright was really good at learning. He learned a big lesson at his first county science fair. He realized that winners do actual experiments instead of just making things look nice.

iii. The book "Travels of Monarch X" introduced the world of science to the enthusiastic young collector. One of his well-known projects was about the idea that viceroy butterflies imitated monarch butterflies to avoid being eaten by birds. This project won first place in the zoology category.

iv. Later, Ebright showed that the spots on a monarch pupa produced a hormone necessary for the butterfly’s development. He also proved that DNA controls heredity and is the blueprint for life.

v. Richard Ebright received all his support, assistance, and motivation from his mother. He was her only companion, and they spent nearly every evening together at the dining table. She motivated his passion for learning.

vi. She bought him telescopes, microscopes, cameras and other instruments for him. Dr. Urquhart helped him with new suggestions and ideas. His Social Studies teacher, Richard A Weiherer, opened his mind to new ideas and made him competitive.

vii. Richard Ebright wasn't just a scientist. He also enjoyed other activities and hobbies. He was great at debating and speaking in public. He was skilled at canoeing and photography. He had a sharp mind, a strong drive to win, and a deep interest in science.
8. Which book proved to be a turning point in Ebright’s life?

Answer : i. One day, Ebright's mom gave him a book called "The Travels of Monarch X." It talked about how monarch butterflies travel to Central America. He found the book really interesting.

ii. At the end of the book, deere invited to help study butterfly migrations. They were asked to tag butterflies for research by Dr. Frederick of Toronto University, Canada. Anyone who found a tagged butterfly was asked to send the tag to Dr. Frederick.

iii. Ebright began putting tags on monarch butterflies. The time for collecting butterflies in Reading only lasts for six weeks in late summer. He understood that chasing after each butterfly wouldn't let him catch many. So, he chose to raise a group of butterflies instead.
9. ‘Success is failure turned inside out’. Prove the above statement with instances from the journey taken by Richard Ebright from losing at the science fair to winning at the international fair.

Answer : i. The saying "Success is failure turned inside out" is shown in Richard Ebright's journey. Despite facing failures, he kept going and eventually succeeded. Even though he was smart, he had challenges while learning about science.

ii. When Richard Ebright was in seventh grade, he took part in the County Science Fair but didn't win with his slides of frog tissues. Instead of quitting, this failure motivated him to try again. In eighth grade, he entered the science fair again, this time with an experiment on viral disease in monarch caterpillars, and he won a prize.

iii. The next year, Ebright joined the science fair with an experiment to see if viceroy butterflies copy monarch butterflies to stay safe from birds. Even though he only got third place in the whole county science fair, he didn't let it bring him down.

iv. He kept following his passion and did experiments about the gold spots on monarch caterpillars. By making a device to show that these spots made hormones needed for butterfly growth, Ebright won third place at the international science and engineering fair.

v. The following year, Ebright's more complex experiments on the monarch pupa got him first place at the international science fair, confirming his achievement. Because he didn't give up, Ebright showed that success often comes from learning from mistakes.

vi. In conclusion, Ebright's journey exemplifies the idea that success can be achieved through perseverance and resilience in the face of failure. Every setback can be turned into an opportunity to learn, grow, and ultimately succeed.
10. “Richard Ebright was a successful scientist who gave a new theory of cells to the scientific world.” Elucidate.

Answer : i. In high school, Ebright conducted experiments on butterflies for a science fair. In his project during his second year, he aimed to understand the reason behind the twelve small gold spots on a Monarch pupa.

ii. He discovered that those spots made a hormone important for a butterfly to grow fully. Even after finishing school, he kept doing experiments using advanced tools from the university.

iii. He found out what the hormone was made of. He developed his own idea about how cells work. This idea answered a question: "How does a cell understand the instructions in DNA?"
11. Ebright’s backbone was his mother. How did she contribute to his learning? What kind of work did she find for him even at the dining table? What values did Ebright imbibe from his mother?

Or
Discuss the role of Ebright’s mother in making him a scientist.


Answer : i. Ebright's mom was key in making him a scientist. She encouraged him to explore and learn. She took him on trips and got him tools like telescopes, microscopes, cameras, and other gear.

ii. Every evening, Ebright and his mother would sit together at the dining table and work. If Ebright didn't have any tasks, she would find him something to learn. He was eager to learn and always received 'A' grades throughout his schooling.

iii. She also got him a book called "The Travels of Monarch X," which sparked his interest in science. Ebright's mother supported his passion for science, helping him become a scientist.
12. What experiments did Ebright do about monarch butterflies?

Answer : i. Ebright sent a letter to Dr. Frederick asking for ideas. The famous scientist gave him lots of suggestions for experiments. These experiments kept Ebright occupied throughout high school. He also won many awards in county and international science fairs.

ii. Ebright tried to find the cause of a viral disease that killed all monarch caterpillars. He thought the disease might be carried by a beetle. He tried raising caterpillars in the presence of beetles. But he didn’t get any real results. But he showed his experiment at the science fair and won.

iii. For the next year's science fair project, Ebright tested whether viceroy butterflies copy monarchs to avoid being eaten by birds. This project won first place in the zoology category and third place overall at the county science fair.
13. Describe Richard Ebright’s various achievements in science, particularly his great work on the monarch butterflies. Who did Ebright look to for getting fresh ideas and suggestions?

Answer : i. Richard Ebright had everything needed to be a scientist. He was smart, competitive, and determined to succeed. Most importantly, he loved collecting things and never stopped being curious about science.

ii. Richard Ebright began his scientific journey at a young age. By second grade, he had gathered every type of butterfly in his hometown. "The Travels of Monarch X" was the book that made a big impact on him, introducing him to the world of science. Failing at his first county science fair taught him an important lesson: winners conduct actual experiments.

iii. One of the most important projects of Richard Ebright was to prove that viceroy butterflies try to look like monarch butterflies. They do so to avoid being eaten by birds. Ebright also proved that twelve tiny gold spots on a monarch pupa produced a hormone that was necessary for the butterfly’s full development.

iv. Another project of his won first prize for zoology at the International Fair. It demonstrated that when cells receive the hormone from the gold spots, they can turn into regular butterfly wing scales. The highlight of Ebright's impressive scientific career was his research on the chemical structure of a hormone. He showed that cells can understand the instructions in DNA, which controls traits passed down from parents and is like the blueprint for life.

v. Richard Ebright sought new ideas and advice from Dr. Urquhart. "The Travels of Monarch X" introduced him to the world of science. He sent tagged butterflies to Dr. Urquhart for research. Dr. Urquhart's ideas and advice helped Ebright win awards in county and International Science Fairs.
14. Describe the contribution of his mother in Richard Ebright’s life. What role did she play in making Ebright a scientist?

Answer : i. Some say that a woman plays a big role in a man's success. In Richard Ebright's case, his success as a scientist and as a person was strongly supported by his mother. Richard Ebright's dad passed away when he was in third grade.

ii. "Richie was everything to me after his father passed away," said his mother. He was her only friend, and they spent almost every evening together at the dining table. Ebright's mother supported his passion for learning. She knew that her son was very curious and smart.

iii. She took him on trips, bought him telescopes, microscopes, cameras, mounting materials and other equipment. She helped Ebright in many ways.

iv. She was an important link between Dr. Urquhart and her son. She wrote to Dr. Urquhart and after her advice, Ebright sent tagged butterflies to him in Canada. She knew that her son had a passion for collecting things. By the time he was in the second grade, Ebright had collected all twenty-five species of butterflies found around his hometown.

vi. If his mom hadn't given him "The Travels of Monarch X," Richard Ebright might have stopped collecting butterflies. The book talked about how monarch butterflies fly to Central America. It introduced the world of science to the enthusiastic collector.
15. How did Richard Ebright not winning anything at his first County Science Fair motivate him to become a great scientist? What lessons did he learn from his failure there?

Answer : i. Richard Ebright began studying butterflies and insects when he was very young. His main focus was on butterflies, especially monarch butterflies.

ii. When he was in second grade, he gathered all 25 types of butterflies from his hometown. But the most important lesson came in seventh grade when he learned about real science.

iii. He joined the County Science Fair with a project. His project was about looking at frog tissues under a microscope. Sadly, he didn't win anything at the fair, while everyone else did. It made him very sad.

iv. At his first county science fair, Ebright learned about real science. He also learned what it takes to win. He realized he made mistakes. Instead of doing real experiments, he only made a nice display of frog tissues under a microscope. He understood that winners had done actual experiments.

v. After that, he relied on Dr. Urquhart for ideas and advice. Dr. Urquhart suggested many experiments to him. His ongoing research and experiments earned him many awards and prizes, both locally and internationally.
16. What other interests, besides science did Richard Ebright pursue? Why did Ebright respect and praise his Social Studies teacher so much?

Answer : i. No doubt, first and foremost, Richard Ebright was a scientist. He was interested in science. He first began to collect butterflies. But this scientist found time for other interests too.

ii. He was a person with many talents—a versatile genius. He not only collected butterflies but also enjoyed other activities. He collected rocks, fossils, and coins. He was also enthusiastic about astronomy. Sometimes, he would spend the whole night looking at the stars.

iii. Ebright also became a champion debater and public speaker. In this field, his Social Studies teacher turned Ebright’s tremendous energy towards the Debating and Model United Nations Clubs.

iv. He was a good canoeist and an all-around outdoors-person. He was also an expert photographer. He excelled in nature and scientific exhibits.

v. In brief, besides being a remarkable scientist, Richard Ebright enjoyed all the pleasures, adventures, hobbies and entertainment that a happy and civilised lifeprovided for him.
17. 'In the field of observation, chance favours only the prepared mind'. This is a popular quote. Examine The Making of a Scientist as a story woven around this quote.

Answer : Richard Ebright was a curious kid who had a knack for observing the life around him and questioning things. He got interested in catching and studying butterflies in kindergarten. Then he started raising them and tagging them for a research study. In his eighth grade, he presented his work in a science fair which won him prize and acclaim. His love for science was evident with how he kept on evolving with the level of advancements in his experiments. He ended up discovering a novel insect hormone, and by the time he was in college, he had started theorising how cells function. He, along with his roommate, devised that DNA is the blueprint for life and published it in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science. This opportunity only fell into his lap because he was prepared for it and honed his skills throughout his life.
18. Often kids pick up a hobby which they are good at but later quickly drop it, not knowing the full potential they can reach. Analyse this in detail, with reference to the story "The making of a Scientist".

Answer : Richard Ebright was a bright but a lonely kid. Being the only child, he didn't have anyone to interact with, except his mother. So, he quickly developed the hobby of collecting insects, fossils, rocks and coins. What started as an engaging activity to wear off loneliness, became a spark of curiosity for him. He later went on collecting and raising butterflies for a scientist's project work. The cascading events in his academic life brought him success, be it winning science fairs, getting admission in Harvard, or having his article published in a scientific journal. All of this could easily be traced back to his hobby of observing and collecting things as a kid. Had he given up on it, he might have had a different trajectory in his life which wouldn't have been this exciting. His precocious nature was rewarded with the much deserving success because of the way he developed his simple hobbies into advanced ideas.
Read and Find Out

1. How did a book become a turning point in Richard Ebright’s life?

Answer : A book called The Travels of Monarch X became a turning point in Richard Ebright’s life. It introduced him to the study of butterfly migration and opened the world of science to him. The book encouraged him to participate in butterfly tagging research, which deepened his interest in science and led to his future discoveries.

2. How did his mother help him?

Answer : Richard Ebright’s mother played a crucial role in shaping his scientific curiosity by encouraging his interests from a young age. She provided him with books, microscopes, telescopes, and other learning tools, took him on educational trips, and spent time teaching him new things at home. After his father passed away, she became his main companion and actively supported his passion for science. She even wrote to scientists, like Dr. Urquhart, to help him with his butterfly research. Her constant guidance and encouragement played a vital role in his journey to becoming a successful scientist.
Read and Find Out

1. What lesson does Ebright learn when he does not win anything at a science fair?
Answer : When Ebright did not win anything at the science fair, he learned that just making a neat display was not enough. He realized that real science involves conducting experiments and making discoveries. This lesson motivated him to work harder and focus on real scientific research in future projects.

2. What experiments and projects does he then undertake?
Answer : After losing at the science fair, Richard Ebright focused on real scientific experiments. He studied a viral disease in monarch caterpillars, tested the theory that viceroy butterflies mimic monarchs to avoid predators, and researched the purpose of the gold spots on a monarch pupa, discovering that they produce a hormone necessary for development. He later grew butterfly wing cells in a lab and proved they needed this hormone to develop properly. His research on insect hormones eventually led to a groundbreaking theory on how cells read DNA, marking a major scientific achievement.

3. What are the qualities that go into the making of a scientist?
Answer : The key qualities that make a scientist are curiosity, perseverance, creativity, and a strong desire to learn. A scientist must ask questions, work hard, think critically, and be open to new ideas. Richard Ebright’s success was driven by his keen observation, determination, and passion for discovery.
Think About it

1. How can one become a scientist, an economist, a historian…? Does it simply involve reading many books on the subject? Does it involve observing, thinking and doing experiments?
Answer : Becoming a scientist, economist, historian, or expert in any field requires more than just reading books. It involves curiosity, observation, critical thinking, and practical experience. Scientists conduct experiments, economists analyze data, and historians study sources and evidence. True learning comes from asking questions, exploring ideas, and applying knowledge to real-world problems.

2. You must have read about cells and DNA in your science books. Discuss Richard Ebright’s work in light of what you have studied. If you get an opportunity to work like Richard Ebright on projects and experiments, which field would you like to work on and why?
Answer : Richard Ebright’s work focused on understanding how cells function and how DNA provides instructions for life. His research on the gold spots of a monarch pupa led to the discovery of an important insect hormone, and his study of cell development contributed to a new theory on how cells read genetic information. This aligns with what we learn about DNA in science books, where DNA acts as a blueprint for an organism’s growth and function.

If given the opportunity to work on projects like Ebright, I would choose the field of genetics and biotechnology because it has the potential to solve major health issues, develop new medicines, and improve human life. The study of DNA can help in curing genetic diseases, improving crops, and even fighting cancer, making it an exciting and impactful field of research.
Talk About it

1. Children everywhere wonder about the world around them. The questions they ask are the beginning of the scientific inquiry. Given below are some questions that children in India have asked Professor Yash Pal and Dr Rahul Pal as reported in their book, Discovered Questions (NCERT, 2006).

(i) What is DNA fingerprinting? What are its uses?
Answer : DNA fingerprinting is a scientific method used to identify individuals based on their unique DNA patterns. It is used in forensic science to solve crimes, in paternity tests to determine biological relationships, and in genetic research to study hereditary diseases.

(ii) How do honeybees identify their own honeycombs?
Answer : Honeybees recognize their own honeycombs using a combination of smell and unique chemical markers called pheromones. Each colony has a distinct scent, which helps bees find their hive even among many others.

(iii) Why does rain fall in drops?
Answer : Rain falls in drops because of surface tension. Water in clouds forms tiny droplets that merge to become larger. When they get heavy enough, gravity pulls them down, and they fall as raindrops instead of a continuous stream.

Practice MCQs

20 multiple-choice questions on The Making of a Scientist. Tap an option to check the answer.

Q. 1
The publishing of Ebright's article in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science was so special because:
A
for the first time, it had published the work of college students.
B
Ebright and his friend had worked hard for this research.
C
it was a new theory on the working of cells.
D
Ebright worked hard to get it published.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 2
At what age did Ebright invent the theory on how cells work?
A
Twenty
B
Twenty one
C
Twenty two
D
Twenty four
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 3
Ebright decided to raise butterflies instead of catching them because:
A
he enjoyed raising the butterflies than catching them.
B
monarch butterflies were found only for a limited time.
C
he wanted to study the life cycle of the butterflies.
D
monarch butterflies were not found there.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 4
Where did Ebright come from?
A
Oxford
B
Reading
C
None of these
D
London
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 5
When did he find the cause of a viral disease common among caterpillars?
A
None of these
B
In the 8th grade
C
In college
D
In the 7th grade
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 6
Select the most appropriate option for (1) and (2)
(1) Starling feeds on viceroys.
(2) Starling does not eat seeds and insects.

A
Both (1) and (2) are false.
B
(1) is false and (2) cannot be clearly inferred from the extract.
C
(1) cannot be clearly inferred from the text but (2) is true.
D
Both (1) and (2) are clearly mentioned in the text.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 7
_________ is the blueprint for life".
A
None of these
B
DNA
C
Cells
D
Both of these
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 8
What was the real purpose of the twelve tiny gold spot on a monarch pupa?
A
They were only ornamental.
B
They were very essential for the butterfly's wings.
C
They produced hormones needed for the growth of the butterfly.
D
They formed the wing of the butterfly.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 9
Which butterflies were not eaten by birds?
A
None of these
B
General
C
Viceroy
D
Monarch
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 10
Who did he write to get an idea for a real science experiment?
A
None of the above
B
His mother
C
Dr. Frederick A. Urquhart
D
His friend
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 11
__________ give that extra efforts refers to Ebright's quality of being:
A
systematic
B
casual
C
perseverant
D
disciplined
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 12
Ebright's eighth grade project was to _________ .
A
find the purpose of gold spot on a monarch pupa.
B
show the slide of frog tissues under the microscope.
C
find the cause of the death of Monarch caterpillars.
D
show the chemical structure of DNA.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 13
he got a hint of what real science is' means Ebright got an idea that real science is________ .
A
displaying any experiment.
B
showing slides under the microscope.
C
displaying of models.
D
doing real experiment.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 14
The book The Travels of Monarch X is about:
A
the characteristics of Monarch butterflies.
B
life cycle of Monarch butterflies.
C
Species X of Monarch butterflies.
D
migration of Monarch butterflies to Central America.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 15
How did Ebright's mother help him?
A
Bought him telescopes and microscopes.
B
Encouraged him to learn.
C
Took him on trips.
D
All of the above
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 16
What did he collect during his childhood?
A
Rocks
B
Coins
C
All of these
D
Butterflies
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 17
What ground breaking research did Ebright do?
A
Working of DNA
B
None of these
C
Working of body
D
Working of heart
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 18
"That probably would have been the end of my butterfly collecting," what could have possibly ended his butterfly collecting?
A
He had collected all species of butterflies of his area
B
His mother did not like it.
C
his disinterest in collecting butterflies.
D
No butterfly was found in his area.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 19
What was the theory about viceroy butterflies?
A
Birds do feed on Viceroys.
B
Monarchs are liked by the birds.
C
Viceroy butterflies resembles Monarch butterflies.
D
Viceroy butterflies copy monarchs to escape being eaten by birds.
Click an option to check your answer
Q. 20
"It was his fascination for ________ that opened the world of science to him."
A
butterflies
B
birds
C
dogs
D
cats
Click an option to check your answer